Research projects completed in 2007-2008

Lots of them; reported elsewhere.

Research projects completed in 2006

1. Imagine heating up ordinary matter to extremely high temperatures - such that in nature they only existed in the early universe but which today can be created in the laboratory for a fleetingly short moment by colliding large nuclei. In ordinary matter its constituents, quarks and gluons are confined in nucleons. However, come to a temperature of about Tc = 1.9*10^12 K the matter undergoes a phase transition to a new phase, the quark-gluon plasma phase, in which quarks and gluons cannot any more be identified to within one nucleon. The goal is to understand the properties of this plasma. The theory controlling it, quantum chromodynamics, is perfectly well known, but the problem is how to get consequences out of it.

If the temperature is still much higher, T > 5Tc, the properties of the plasma can with controlled accuracy be computed in an effective theory approach, pioneered by the group at TFO. This effort is still continuing. The range Tc
The method thus implies that one goes to a world with one more dimension, writes down Einstein gravity equations in it, solves them and then goes back to the boundary, a four dimensional world. Quantum physics in our usual 4d space is then obtained from the boundary values of the 5d theory. Having finite temperature on the boundary implies that there is a black hole deep in the 5d space. However, the gravity equations giving correct QCD physics are not yet known. We have explored (hep-ph/0609254) various alternatives by deriving their consequences and by comparing with various known facts about QCD: the numerical value of Tc, the spectrum of hadrons and the quark-antiquark potential. As the experiments producing quark-gluon plasma are very strongly time dependent, it is also of great importance to find out what kind of 5d physics would correspond to such time dependent phenomena. We have presented (hep-ph/0609254) an exact time dependent 5d solution which corresponds to radially expanding hot matter in 4d. Various properties related to thermalisation of the hot matter can be read from this solution.

2. Weak coupling expansion of hot QCD pressure can be calculated in the framework of perturbation theory only up to order g^6 log(g). However the g^6 term can be determined with a combination of analytical computation and non-perturbative lattice simulation. The total non-perturbative input for the g^6 term of hot QCD pressure was measured by lattice simulations for arbitary number of colors in hep-lat/0609015, for three colors it was measured by us in hep-lat/0412008.

Research projects completed in 2003

1. A natural continuation of the recent progress made in computing the QCD pressure up to order g^6 log(g) at zero net quark density was the extension of the result to finite chemical potentials \mu, which we completed in hep-ph/0305183. This furthermore enabled us to calculate predictions for different quark number susceptibilities at \mu=0 (see also hep-ph/0212283), which by now have been tested on the lattice and in the large flavor number limit of the theory with promising results. Continuing on the same path, we together with A. Ipp and A. Rebhan (Vienna Tech. Univ.) analyzed the breakdown of dimensional reduction at large \mu/T by comparing the outcome of the perturbative calculation with the exact large-N_f pressure in this limit [hep-ph/0311200] - with the result that the onset of the breakdown appears to happen only when the parameter \mu/T reaches values of order 10. This is in clear contrast with earlier estimates suggesting a critical parameter value \mu/T=4.


2. As an important preliminary step for the eventual order g^6 computation of the QCD pressure we together with Y. Schröder (MIT) published a high-precision evaluation of the four-loop skeleton graphs of three-dimensional field theories [hep-ph/0311323]. The calculation was based on constructing systems of difference equations for the graphs and subsequestly solving them by applying a novel algorithm developed by S. Laporta (Bologna). It is anticipated that our results will be of use not only to the QCD community but also in the context of condensed matter theory.


3. The calculation of the phase diagram of the electroweak theory was extended by considering how a finite net lepton number density (= finite chemical potentials for leptons) affects the system [hep-ph/0303019]. This was done by generalizing the succesful effective field theory methods to finite chemical potentials. Since the form of the effective theory is unaffected by the chemical potentials, the same nonperturbative calculations can be used to deduce the phase diagram as in the absence of chemical potentials. We observed that the critical temperature increases and, more importantly, the value of the Higgs boson mass corresponding to the critical end point of the first order phase transition line decreases as the chemical potentials are increased.


4. The number of gluons produced in a heavy-ion collision in the McLerran-Venugopalan classical field model was computed numerically [hep-ph/0303076]. The calculation corrected an error of a factor of two in earlier calculations by Krasnitz, Nara and Venugopalan, showing that the classical field model fits in with realistic scenarios for understanding the transverse energy and multiplicity observed at RHIC.


5. One of the characteristic features of any plasma is screening. While the screening of gluonic operators in hot QCD is a well-studied subject, the large systematic errors related to light dynamical fermions have so far prevented the reliable determination of mesonic and baryonic screening correlators on the lattice. Together with M. Laine, we calculated the next-to-leading order correction to mesonic screening masses in perturbation theory using effective field theory methods, and found a gauge invariant, IR safe result [hep-ph/0311268] that differs qualitatively from the previous lattice studies.


Research projects completed in 2002

1. The project of computing the free energy of hot quark-gluon plasma nonperturbatively at any energies has been advanced significantly by the computation of the coefficient of the g^6 log(g) term in the perturbative expansion of the free energy by Kajantie, Laine, Rummukainen and Schröder [hep-ph/0211321]. This is actually the last coefficient calculable by perturbative means; beyond that only fully numerical methods seem to be the only method for obtaining first-principle results. Historically, it is notable that the previous and the only other logarithmic term, of order g^4 log(g), was also computed in Helsinki by T. Toimela already in 1983. New progress was only possible due to the development of new techniques of symbolic computation.


2. The quark number susceptibility of hot quark-gluon plasma physically characterises how easy it is to produce quark-antiquark pairs. For the theoretical analysis of its measurements by numerical lattice Monte Carlo techniques one needs its perturbative expansion. This has been known only up to order g^4 log(g), also thanks to T. Toimela. Now the terms of order g^4, g^5 and g^6 log(g) have been computed in one clean sweep by A. Vuorinen [hep-ph/0212283].


Research projects completed in 2001

1. The most ambitious project, started already in 1999, has been developing a first-principle numerical method of controllable accuracy to compute the equation of state for QCD matter from about 2Tc to practically infinite temperatures, using effective field theory methods. This is a purely theoretical effort since experiments cannot conceivably probe temperatures above about 10Tc, but it is a pure ab initio computation in QCD and as such very important. The work is carried out jointly with Mikko Laine (now at CERN, Geneva), Kari Rummukainen (now at Nordita, Copenhagen) and York Schröder (now at MIT, Boston). The general outline of the method has been published in Physical Review Letters [hep-ph/0109100] but the detailed implementation is technically very complicated and demands extensive numerical simulations (Rummukainen) at equally extensive symbolic computations (Schröder). One might add that expressions with of the order of 10 million terms easily appear at intermediate stages of the computation. As a spin-off we also have developed general diagrammatic techniques, presented in [hep-ph/0109100]


2. With coworkers in Jyväskylä we have already some time ago suggested (Eskola, Kajantie, Ruuskanen, Tuominen, [hep-ph/9909456]) that the growth of the number of produced partons in nuclear collisions at small transverse momenta is inhibited at sufficiently large densities. Based on the conjecture of saturation and on a subsequent isentropic expansion stage, we have predicted particle multiplicities for central A+A collisions at various nucleon numbers A and total energies s. The first results from RHIC indeed confirmed our prediction amazingly well, both in absolute magnitude and in the energy dependence. This model has been further applied to various new phenomena in Eskola, Kajantie, Tuominen, hep-ph/0009246 and hep-ph/0106330.


3. Our particle physics-motivated field theories have also led us to apply the same techniques to a prototype condensed matter theory: the Ginzburg-Landau model in three dimensions. This is well known as the coarse-grained theory of superconductivity. Surprisingly, it is not precisely known what this theory says about the properties of the transition in the type II region, which corresponds to high Tc superconductors. This probably is not relevant for real-life superconductors, since they are not really sensitive to quantum fluctuations, but is a very relevant question about the theory itself. It namely also answers the question whether the theory could alternatively be described by a dual theory, in which non-local vortices of the GL theory have become local fields, and which perhaps could be more easily solved. We (also Laine, Neuhaus (now in Bielefeld), Rajantie (now at Cambridge), Rummukainen) have, in spite of extensive simulations, not been able to solve the problem, the dynamics is so involved that definite final conclusions cannot be drawn. Tentative ones were reported in hep-lat/0110062.